this or that: Aldo vs Jeffrey Campbell

I have a deep affection for Jeffrey Campbell shoes and to my amazement was shocked to see that Aldo had ripped them off and come up with their own version. Not only do they look identical, they are only a few dollars cheaper, which really does not make sense to me. I love both pairs of boots and I want them desperately. Although I'm already 5'7'' I don't care how tall they make me, I need them in my closet.

This begs the question of which ones would you go for? And can you tell the difference?

Looks are deceiving friends!